2037 matches of Age of Empires II are on Tolkien's record. Tolkien excels in the flank position: 54.1% win rate over 98 matches. The RM Team win rate for Tolkien is 53.7% in 402 games.

Tolkien represents United States in ranked random map 1v1, most often selecting Britons (4.5%). Tolkien has reached 1132 in RM Team. They win 65.2% with Franks and 51.7% on Arabia.